|
13:56 Tue 13.10.26 |
Liability for Ignoring a advocate's request: what's missing in practice |
|
Refusal to provide information in response to a lawyer’s request, untimely or incomplete provision of information, or provision of false information entail liability under Part 5 of Article 212-3 of the Code of Administrative Offenses. However, in practice, it is not enough to simply establish the fact of a violation. Due to a number of problems, violators often go unpunished. Among the main issues are difficulties in identifying the perpetrator and a lack of evidence. A lawyer’s request may be addressed to a government agency, a local government body, a business, an institution, or an organization, while its actual review is carried out by a specific official. At the same time, the person who directly drafted or signed the response is not always the person who, in accordance with their official duties, is responsible for ensuring the timely and proper consideration of the attorney’s inquiry. The mere information regarding the position and last name of the person who signed the response to the attorney’s inquiry is insufficient to conclude that their actions constitute an administrative offense. It is necessary to establish their official duties and authority, as well as to confirm that this specific person was responsible for the proper consideration of the attorney’s inquiry. To properly document the case, it is necessary to establish the details of the person subject to liability — last name, first name and patronymic; position; taxpayer identification number; residential address; and other necessary information. However, obtaining such information presents difficulties. Consequently, a related problem is compliance with the time limits for bringing administrative liability proceedings, as provided for in Article 38 of the Code of Administrative Offenses. To address these issues, the UNBA established a Committee on the prevention of administrative offenses committed against advocates in 2024. Its activities are aimed at establishing the legal and organizational framework for monitoring administrative offenses involving advocates, as well as developing and implementing preventive mechanisms to prevent such offenses. An important part of the Committee’s work is developing a protocol for action. Advocates and authorized representatives of bar associations who draft reports on administrative liability must understand the procedure for documenting violations and collecting the necessary evidence. This article was prepared by a member of the UNBA Committee on the prevention of administrative offenses committed against advocates Nazar Sayuk. |
|
|
© 2026 Unba.org.ua Всі права захищені |
|