|
15:16 Mon 09.11.26 |
Would a clerical error in an FLA advocate’s report serve as grounds for terminating the contract? |
|
Even a technical error in a document or calculation that an advocate in the free secondary legal aid system submits to the FLA center for payment of their services may be classified as improper performance of the contract with the center and serve as grounds for its termination. Chairman of the UNBA Committee on FLA Oksana Kadenko drew attention to the risks arising from the amendments made by Resolution No. 1374 of the Cabinet of Ministers dated November 4, 2026, to Appendix 2 of the Procedure and Conditions for concluding contracts with advocates who provide free secondary FLA. As a reminder, pursuant to Article 17 of the Law «On legal aid», the Center for the provision of legal aid enters into contracts with advocates listed in the Register of advocates providing secondary legal aid to provide such assistance. The aforementioned resolution amended the form of the Model Contract. In particular, a new clause was added stipulating that the advocate is responsible for the accuracy of the information submitted to the Center, including that contained in reports, calculations, and their attachments, memoranda, certificates, statistical data, and other reporting documents that serve as the basis for payment for their services. Consequently, any inaccurate information in a document or calculation including clerical errors can now formally be classified as improper performance of the contract’s terms. In the event of non-performance or improper performance of the contract’s terms, the Center may terminate the contract early (subparagraph 4 of paragraph 14 of the Model Contract), refer the matter to the Commission for evaluating the quality of legal aid or to the Qualification and Disciplinary Commission of the Bar, as well as petition the Coordination Center to remove the specialist from the Register of advocates providing secondary legal aid (clause 6 of the Model Agreement). «The requirement to submit accurate reports is, in and of itself, entirely justified. The problem is that the provision does not distinguish between an error and bad faith. A clerical error in the date or an arithmetic inaccuracy in a calculation formally falls under the same liability as, for example, a deliberate overstatement of the volume of assistance provided», - O. Kadenko pointed out. In her opinion, such broad wording is a factor that fosters corruption. «In fact, the new contractual provision provides a tool for exerting pressure and creates additional opportunities for the system to get rid of an undesirable advocate by citing identified inaccuracies in reports, - explained the chairman of the relevant Committee of the UNBA. - It is clear that liability must be proportional to the violation; however, the changes leave room for abuse». Resolution No. 1374 will take effect upon its official publication. |
|
|
© 2026 Unba.org.ua Всі права захищені |
|