|
18:06 Thu 12.11.26 |
The advocate's laptop and phones, which had been seized during a search, were returned to him |
|
An advocate whose work laptop and three cell phones were seized during a search has had his devices returned. The Office of the Prosecutor General announced this in response to a request from the relevant Committee of the UNBA, which had demanded an investigation into violations of the guarantees of legal practice. Investigators from the Main Investigative Directorate of the National Police conducted a search of the advocate’s residence in the Kyiv region in September of this year based on a ruling by an investigating judge. A representative of the Committee for the protection of lawyers’ rights and guarantees of legal practice of the Kyiv Regional Bar Association Ruslan Manzhenko participated in the investigative proceedings. During the search, the advocate stated that the electronic devices were his work tools and contained client materials, contracts, procedural documents, and correspondence that is, attorney-client privilege. He granted access to the devices so that the data necessary for the proceedings could be copied with the assistance of a specialist without seizing the storage media. Despite this, the investigators seized a laptop and three cell phones. It is noteworthy that the court order permitted the seizure of computer equipment and mobile phones only under certain conditions, specifically if access to them was restricted by the owner or if it was necessary to bypass a security system. The same grounds for temporary seizure are provided for in Part 2 of Article 168 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In his written comments on the protocol, R. Manzhenko noted that the investigators examined a cell phone, a laptop, a hard drive, and a flash drive, which might contain information protected by attorney-client privilege. The devices were seized, even though only the necessary information could have been copied. «The advocate did everything possible to minimize interference with his professional activities: he invoked attorney-client privilege and allowed only the necessary information to be copied, - R. Manzhenko emphasized. - Instead, for over a month, he had no working equipment, was unable to fully fulfill his contracts with clients, and their information was beyond his control». On September 23, the advocate appealed to the Committee for the protection of lawyers’ rights and guarantees of legal practice of the Ukrainian National Bar Association. After reviewing the appeal, the Committee sent letters to the General Prosecutor’s Office and the State Bureau of Investigations demanding an investigation into the alleged interference in the lawyer’s practice and, if signs of a criminal offense are found, to enter the information into the Unified Register of Pre-trial Investigations. The Committee sees possible signs of a crime under Article 397 (Interference with the Activities of a Defense Attorney or Representative) of the Criminal Code in the actions of the officials. As a reminder, pursuant to Article 22 of the Law «On the advocacy and the practice of law», attorney-client privilege includes, in particular, information stored on electronic media. Article 23 of the Law prohibits the inspection and seizure of documents related to the practice of law. Article 236 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires that a search be conducted only to the extent necessary to achieve its purpose. The UNBA will monitor the Committee’s review of these complaints. |
|
|
© 2026 Unba.org.ua Всі права захищені |
|