16:14 Fri 13.11.26

A complaint against a judge is an advocate's legal right: the Supreme Court recused the judge due to a conflict of interest

print version

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court recused one of its judges from the case: an advocate had filed a disciplinary complaint against him, and the judge had reported interference in his work to the High Council of Justice and the prosecutor’s office. The court emphasized that the advocate had exercised his right under the law, but that such a situation could cast doubt on the judge’s impartiality.

This ruling by the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court dated November 5, 2026, in Case No. 990SCGC/4/25 has been published in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions.

The case concerns a district court judge whom the High Council of Justice brought before disciplinary proceedings. He appealed this decision to the Grand Chamber, and an advocate is representing his interests in court.

The advocate cited a personal conflict with one of the Grand Chamber judges who was hearing the case. He filed a disciplinary complaint against the judge with the High Council of Justice. The Grand Chamber judge informed the High Council of Justice that the advocate was interfering with his work. He also filed a report regarding the interference with the Office of the Prosecutor General and linked the interference specifically to the complaint filed against him. The advocate believed that, taken together, these circumstances raised reasonable doubt as to the judge’s impartiality and filed a motion to recuse him.

The Grand Chamber itself reviewed the motion: under the Code of Administrative Procedure, a motion to recuse a Grand Chamber judge is not referred to another judge. The Code permits the recusal of a judge, in particular, when there are circumstances that cast doubt on his or her impartiality or objectivity.

First, the appeals themselves were evaluated. According to the Grand Chamber’s conclusion, the advocate and the judge exercised their statutory right to appeal to the competent authorities to report circumstances which, in their opinion, required investigation and action. Such appeals, in and of themselves, do not indicate a biased attitude on the part of either the judge toward the advocate or the advocate toward the judge.

At the same time, the Grand Chamber took into account that the situation that arose following these complaints could objectively influence how the judge’s impartiality would be perceived by the parties to the case and outside observers. To avoid such doubts, the court granted the motion and recused the judge from hearing the case.

The ruling took legal effect upon signing and is not subject to appeal. The Grand Chamber will consider any complaint against the High Council of Justice’s decision without the participation of the recused judge.

© 2026 Unba.org.ua Всі права захищені
"Національна Асоціація Адвокатів України". Передрук та інше використання матеріалів, що розміщені на даному веб-сайті дозволяється за умови посилання на джерело. Інтернет-видання та засоби масової інформації можуть використовувати матеріали сайту, розміщувати відео з офіційного веб-сайту Національної Асоціації Адвокатів України на власних веб-сторінках, за умови гіперпосилання на офіційний веб-сайт Національної Асоціації Адвокатів України. Заборонено передрук та використання матеріалів, у яких міститься посилання на інші інтернет-видання та засоби масової інформації. Матеріали позначені міткою "Реклама", публікуються на правах реклами.