Courts need scientific criteria for evaluating expert opinions – V. Fedchyshyna

Advocacy
16:15 Fri 30.05.25 599 Reviews
Print

Ukraine has no clear requirements for verifying the accuracy of expert opinions. The court must assess them in terms of professionalism, logic, and validity, identify errors, and evaluate each piece of evidence, taking into account all the materials of the case.

This was pointed out by the chairwoman of the UNBA Committee on Expert Support for Advocacy, Violleta Fedchyshyna, during the International Scientific and Practical Conference «Current Issues of Forensic Examination and Criminalistics». The event was held on May 23 at the National Scientific Center «Institute of Forensic Expertise named after Honored Professor M.S. Bokarius».

The UNBA representative delivered a report on the topic «Scientific criteria for evaluating expert opinion». In particular, she recalled that the conclusion of a forensic expert, drawn up on the basis of special knowledge, is one of the sources of evidence. And it cannot be replaced by other evidence.

At the same time, the assessment of the objectivity and validity of the conclusion is the most controversial and debatable in the judicial process. After all, the specificity of the assessment of such evidence lies in the fact that the substantive sphere of opinion is assessed by a court that does not have special knowledge and, in fact, assesses the expert's conclusion only from the point of view of compliance with the principles of logical thinking and general knowledge. When appointing an expert examination, the court cannot decide on the methods and means to be used by the expert in the course of the investigation, as this choice belongs exclusively to the person with special knowledge.

At the same time, when evaluating evidence according to its own conviction, the court must correctly assess the evidence.

That is why, according to V. Fedchyshyna, the court needs scientific criteria for evaluating the facts presented in the expert's conclusion in the relevant field of specialization. This necessitates the creation of transparent approaches to providing methodological assistance and guidance to both courts and experts.

The conference «Current Issues of Forensic Examination and Criminalistics» was dedicated to the 150th anniversary of the birth of the renowned criminalist, Doctor of Science, Professor Rudolf Archibald Reis.

It was attended by forensic experts, scientists from higher education and research institutions, law enforcement officials, courts, and other specialists in the fields of law, criminalistics, and forensic science.

The participants discussed Reis's scientific legacy, which became the basis for modern methods of criminal investigation and the introduction of expert technologies. The focus was on topical issues of forensic science and criminalistics, the latest achievements in these fields, and ways for further development. Separate emphasis was placed on the importance of putting the results of theoretical research into practice and sharing experience and best practices among experts.

Popular news

Guarantees in the event of detention and procedures for military personnel: recommendations from the UNBA Committee

Legal defence of military personnel

Guarantees in the event of detention and procedures for military personnel: recommendations from the UNBA Committee

Most often, military personnel turn to advocates regarding frozen bank accounts and delays in discharge. Step-by-step procedures have been prepared for such situations. A guide on one-time financial assistance has been provided for the families of those killed in action. And the new regulations governing the stay of mobilized individuals at TCCs require changes regarding guarantees of communication with an advocate.

18:12 Fri 30.10.26 124
Lidiya Izovitova: reform of the advocacy profession should make the profession stronger and individuals better protected

Rule of Law Roadmap

Lidiya Izovitova: reform of the advocacy profession should make the profession stronger and individuals better protected

The Ukrainian advocacy community is finalizing work on a new version of the relevant law. The roadmap on the rule of law has set the fourth quarter of 2026 as the deadline for achieving results in this area. The draft is intended to ensure safeguards for the practice of law through mechanisms of accountability for violations.

14:01 Fri 30.10.26 185
The first country to ratify the Convention on the Protection of the Professions of Lawyer

Abroad

The first country to ratify the Convention on the Protection of the Professions of Lawyer

Bosnia and Herzegovina became the first country to ratify the Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of the Professions of Lawyer (CETS No. 226). The country signed the Convention on March 17, 2026, so it took just over seven months to ratify it.

12:17 Fri 30.10.26 169
Civil security and guidelines for investors: representatives of the UNBA attend a forum in Prague

Discussion

Civil security and guidelines for investors: representatives of the UNBA attend a forum in Prague

How to establish a business in Ukraine, protect investments, and comply with regulatory requirements — these were the issues that foreign companies in the security sector discussed with representatives of the UNBA during an international forum in Prague.

11:57 Fri 30.10.26 101
An emergency search without a warrant? What changes are advocates proposing to the CPC

Legislation

An emergency search without a warrant? What changes are advocates proposing to the CPC

The Verkhovna Rada is preparing a consolidated draft of amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code regarding searches in urgent cases without a prior ruling by an investigating judge. The UNBA insists that judicial oversight following such a search must be effective, and that homeowners must be full participants in the procedure.

12:14 Thu 29.10.26 118
Seizure does not mean return: how to get an exchange to return stolen crypto assets

Discussion

Seizure does not mean return: how to get an exchange to return stolen crypto assets

In cases involving cryptocurrency theft, the assets move faster than the criminal proceedings, so it is best to first freeze and seize them, and only then identify the perpetrator. However, even a seizure will not recover the funds unless the court order specifies exactly what the exchange or issuer must do.

17:29 Fri 23.10.26 129
In Edinburgh expressed gratitude to those who are helping Ukrainian advocates and citizens

Support

In Edinburgh expressed gratitude to those who are helping Ukrainian advocates and citizens

Since the start of the full-scale invasion, Scottish legal institutions and the Ukrainian community, with the participation of the UNBA, have been helping Ukrainian advocates obtain their qualifications and Ukrainians receive legal assistance. The parties are now planning joint professional and educational events.

11:24 Fri 23.10.26 161
What to do when you need immediate protection in the LCIA

Educational events

What to do when you need immediate protection in the LCIA

A dispute with a counterparty has been referred to the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA), but it will take several weeks to appoint the arbitrators, and the client needs legal representation immediately? This can be achieved through an emergency arbitrator or expedited tribunal formation.

14:16 Thu 22.10.26 145

Надішліть файл із текстом публікації у форматі *.doc, фотографію за тематикою у розмірі 640х400 та Ваше фото.

Оберіть файл