Venice Commission warned of risks of changes to disciplinary procedures for Ukrainian judges
The European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission) and the Council of Europe Directorate for Human Rights and Rule of Law are preparing an assessment of draft laws concerning the judicial system and the status of judges in Ukraine.
Lidiya Izovitova, the President of the Ukrainian National Bar Association, the Bar Council of Ukraine, took part in consultations held yesterday, July 24.
She reported that the highest body of the bar self-government had approved a conclusion on draft laws Nos. 13165, 13165-1, and 13165-2, which was sent to all members of the Venice Commission and the Council of Europe Office in Ukraine.
In particular, L. Izovitova spoke about the introduction of the institution of temporary suspension of a judge from the administration of justice for up to four months in connection with disciplinary proceedings, with a categorical prohibition on appealing such a decision.
According to the Ukrainian National Bar Association, this creates three critical problems:
First, it violates the constitutional principles of independence of the judiciary, the right to a fair trial, and the right to legal assistance. The prohibition of appeal makes defense illusory.
Second, criminal procedure mechanisms are being unjustifiably transferred to disciplinary proceedings, where there are no a priori risks to society.
Third, it creates a basis for manipulation, where disciplinary complaints can be used to remove «inconvenient» judges, creating an atmosphere of fear among judges.
The Bar Council of Ukraine concluded that the changes are conceptually unjustified and systematically dangerous for independent justice.
The President of the UNBA, BCU also drew the attention of international experts to violations of international legal norms.
The proposed mechanism, as it prohibits appeals against decisions on the temporary suspension of judges, is contrary to Article 6 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which guarantees the right to a fair trial and an effective remedy.
The mechanism also does not comply with the 1985 UN Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary, which prohibit external pressure on judges without appropriate procedural guarantees.
Therefore, the application of repressive measures against a judge before the fact of a violation has been established is contrary to the presumption of innocence and the principle of proportionality, concluded L. Izovitova. Such changes transform the legal system from an instrument of justice into a mechanism of control.
The President of the UNBA, BCU expressed her conviction that any changes to the legislation on the judiciary must be balanced, proportionate and strengthen the independence of the judiciary, rather than creating risks for interference in the administration of justice.
Popular news
Educational events
Ukrainian advocacy integrates HELP into the system of professional development
In recent years, the Ukrainian National Bar Association has become one of the Council of Europe’s key partners in implementing the HELP programme, an educational project aimed at developing the legal profession through training in European human rights standards.
Legislation
Those who equate advocates with clients will be fined – law passed
Public identification of an advocate with a client to whom such advocate provides professional legal assistance will become an administrative offense, and forms of interference in the activities of an advocate, for which liability is provided for in Article 397 of the Criminal Code, are detailed.
Discussion
Experts have exceptional potential that should be developed jointly — Lidiya Izovitova
The professions of advocate and expert can and must develop by learning from each other, exchanging experience and best practices. Together, we can build a strong, independent, and effective justice system worthy of a European Ukraine.
Discussion
Strengthening the country's sovereignty requires a new model for forming the HQCJ – round table
The model of the competition commission for selecting members of the High Qualification Commission of Judges, introduced as an anti-crisis measure, has exhausted itself. The inaction of the HCJ in forming a new composition of the CC, the lack of accountability, and the existing signs of political influence indicate that powers should be transferred directly to the entities responsible for forming the HQCJ as defined by law.
Guarantees of the practice of law
UNBA Committee reviews new cases of violence against advocates in TCC
New facts of physical violence, obstruction of access to clients, as well as sabotage of investigations in cases involving lawyers were considered by the UNBA Committee on the Protection of Lawyers' Rights and Guarantees of the Legal Profession during its last meeting.
Guarantees of the practice of law
One third of complaints to the UNBA are due to unlawful actions by the TCC
In the first half of 2025, the Committee for the protection of lawyers' rights and guarantees of advocacy of the Ukrainian National Bar Association recorded 46 complaints of violations of professional rights. A third of these concerned unlawful actions by territorial recruitment centers—systematic obstruction of advocacy or violation of the right to defense.
Guarantees of the practice of law
SSU official letter about «dangerous» advocacy turned out to be fake
The Security Service of Ukraine has officially denied the authenticity of a document that allegedly described threatening trends in the development of the advocacy profession. The text, which was previously published on a little-known website and distributed on Telegram channels, is not an official letter from the SSU.
Self-government
The HCJ continues to ignore the legal deadlines for forming the Competition Commission of the HQCJ
The High Council of Justice continues to violate the statutory deadlines for forming a new competition commission to select members of the Competition Commission of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine.
Publications
Ihor Kolesnykov A BRIEF SUMMARY REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDER ON EXTENDED CONFISCATION IN LATVIA REGARDING FINANCIAL ASSETS OF…
Valentyn Gvozdiy WORKING IN A WAR ZONE
Lydia Izovitova Formula of perfection
Sergiy Vylkov Our judicial system is so built that courts do not trust advocates
Iryna Vasylyk Advocacy in the proclamation of Independence of Ukraine
Oleksandr DULSKY When we cross the border of the Supreme Anti-Corruption Court, we get into another department of the National Anti-Corruption…
Vadym Krasnyk The UNBA will work, and all obstacles and restrictions are only temporary inconveniences
Lydia Izovitova Interview with Lydia Izovitova on the occasion of the 8th anniversary of the founding of UNBA: We are the voice of t…
