Amendments to Free legal aid, proposed by the Ministry of Justice, undermine human rights

Legislation
15:00 Mon 03.05.21 1060 Reviews
Print

Draft law №5107 "On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts to Facilitate Access to Free Legal Aid and Improve the Quality of Legal Aid" is an example of defiant human rights violations.

This was stated by UNBA\BCU Vice-President Valentyn Gvozdiy during the panel discussion "Development of quality standards for free legal aid in civil and administrative cases."

The event took place online as part of the Council of Europe Project "Support to the Judiciary of Ukraine in Ensuring Better Access to Justice".

In his welcoming speech, Valentyn Gvozdiy voiced UNBA official position on the amendnents, which is set out in numerous decisions of the BCU and appeals to Ukrainian authorities and international legal organizations. He stressed that after analyzing the documents, the UNBA is convinced that authors of the proposed changes blindly copied the experience of other countries, without considering the features of national legislation.

«We urge not to blindly copy other countries` experiences. Yes, indeed, such experience is important. However, we must consider our experience and traditions as well, and respect our Constitution. Otherwise, we will not build the sovereign and independent state», - noted Valentin Gvozdiy.

The Deputy Head of the UNBA, the BCU believes that the introduction of a mechanism for assessing the quality of free legal aid provided by attorneys using "peer review" is an attempt to encroach on the legal professional privilege, which is a gross violation of all principles and standards of advocacy.

"Today, free legal aid exists to protect the most vulnerable segments of the population, those people who are unable to provide legal protection and legal aid on their own. This law takes away the last thing from them - the right to the attorney-client privilege and so on. And the cynicism is that with one hand the state will assist, with the other - it will violate people's rights", - Valentyn Gvozdiy stressed.

The UNBA is also concerned about who will evaluate the quality of the provided free legal aid (hereinafter - FLA). Thus, by the provisions of these bills, such an assessment will be conducted by a special commission, to which attorneys-experts will be selected by the Ministry of Justice.

"We believe that the provision of legal assistance by dubious subjects, as proposed in the bill - is a bold mockery of vulnerable groups," - said Valentin Gvozdiy.

He also drew attention to the fact that these bills were prepared without the participation of the direct participants in these changes - the attorneys` community.

«The Ministry of Justice has not addressed us with any inquiries, has not analyzed the work of the commission on the quality of Free legal aid so far. We can say that complaints about the quality of the FLA provided today are minimal. We have proposed different approaches to how the quality of FLA can be improved. And we believe that it is not right to interfere in the attorney-client privilege and to humiliate recipients of FLA through such procedures», - he stressed.

Valentyn Gvozdiy expressed hope for better communication between the Ministry of Justice and the UNBA and the involvement of the attorneys` community in the process of drafting not only bills but also other mechanisms of work in the field of free legal aid.

It will be recalled that in April Bar Council of Ukraine called for the draft laws “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts Concerning Simplification of Access to Free Legal Aid and Improving the Quality of Its Provision” №5107  dated  February 19, 2021, and “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts Concerning simplification of access to free legal aid and improvement of the quality of its provision ” №5107-1 dated March 9, 2021, were sent for revision, as they were prepared and registered without the participation of the attorneys` community.

After analyzing these bills, the UNBA has identified numerous problems and serious shortcomings that are contrary to international law and should be resolved at the legislative level solely by the joint efforts of state bodies and bar self-government bodies. The UNBA believes that the proposed bills are not aimed at improving the quality of FLA, but other grounds, not excluding obtaining serious leverage over independent attorneys and obtaining additional budget funding to establish and ensure the activities of the commission proposed by the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine or other commissions.

After analyzing these bills, UNBA has identified numerous problems and serious shortcomings that are contrary to international law and should be resolved at the legislative level solely by the joint efforts of state bodies and bar self-government bodies. UNBA believes that the proposed bills are not aimed at improving the quality of FLA, but other grounds, not excluding obtaining serious leverage over independent attorneys and obtaining additional budget funding to establish and ensure the activities of the commission proposed by the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine or other commissions.

The previous draft Law “On Amendments to Certain Laws of Ukraine on Facilitating Access to Free Legal Aid for Children and Persons with Disabilities and Improving the Quality of Its Provision” with similar proposals was registered under №702704 dated December 28, 2019, but was withdrawn on March 14, 2020, after the categorical objections from the Ukrainian National Bar Association.

BCU has repeatedly opposed the introduction of such a mechanism to control the quality of professional legal assistance provided by attorneys in any form.

In the decision №33 of April 1, BCU decided to send an appeal to the President of Ukraine, the Head of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, the Head of the Verkhovna Rada Committee on Legal Policy, the Prime Minister of Ukraine, and the Minister of Justice of Ukraine on the return (revocation, rejection) of bills № 5107 and revision of the bill № 5107-1.

 

Popular news

Shoulder straps do not fit the robe: Lidiya Izovitova analyzes models of military courts restoration

Advocacy

Shoulder straps do not fit the robe: Lidiya Izovitova analyzes models of military courts restoration

The Verkhovna Rada Committee on Legal Policy held a working meeting to discuss draft laws that provide for the establishment and operation of military courts in Ukraine on a permanent basis. The Institute of Advocacy presented its reservations regarding this initiative.

15:39 Thu 01.05.25 113
UNBA Committee for the protection of advocates' rights responds to accusations regarding the case of «hacker lawyers»

Advocacy

UNBA Committee for the protection of advocates' rights responds to accusations regarding the case of «hacker lawyers»

Dzerkalo Tyzhnia's publications about «hacker lawyers» contain false information, distortions and manipulations that undermine the authority of the Bar. They are a form of unlawful pressure on the UNBA and may be an element of a paid-for campaign.

19:17 Wed 23.04.25 119
Problems of implementation of the Convention on the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer discussed in the Verkhovna Rada

Advocacy

Problems of implementation of the Convention on the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer discussed in the Verkhovna Rada

On April 16, the Verkhovna Rada Committee on Legal Policy held a joint working meeting to discuss the feasibility of implementing the provisions of the Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer and introducing the necessary amendments to the current legislation.

18:41 Wed 16.04.25 172
The BCU creates a working group to monitor violations of the rights of lawyers and will consider appealing to the Verkhovna Rada

Advocacy

The BCU creates a working group to monitor violations of the rights of lawyers and will consider appealing to the Verkhovna…

During an extraordinary meeting on April 16, 2025, the Bar Council of Ukraine decided to establish a working group to monitor and summarize the facts of violations of the rights of lawyers and guarantees of the practice of law over the past three years, including the situation with the detention of lawyer Olga Panchenko.

14:16 Wed 16.04.25 125
Temporary protection, work, study: what Ukrainians should know about France and UK

Advocacy

Temporary protection, work, study: what Ukrainians should know about France and UK

What is the procedure for obtaining temporary protection status in France and the UK? When can it be refused and is it possible to appeal such a decision? What are the options for legalization and change of status? What about employment, education and business opportunities?

18:36 Tue 01.04.25 236
«Military advocates» have nothing to do with advocacy – UNBA statement

Advocacy

«Military advocates» have nothing to do with advocacy – UNBA statement

The activities of the «military advocates» who forcefully «repel» mobilized persons liable for military service in the TCC have nothing to do with legal practice based on the principles of the rule of law and legality.

17:32 Fri 28.03.25 271
Commentary to the Council of Europe Convention on the protection of the profession of lawyer translated into Ukrainian

Advocacy

Commentary to the Council of Europe Convention on the protection of the profession of lawyer translated into Ukrainian

Along with the Convention on the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe also approved an explanatory report to it. This document is a kind of official commentary to be used by countries in the application of the international treaty.

15:37 Mon 24.03.25 237
«The Convention will enhance the quality of human protection from criminal prosecution», - Valentyn Gvozdiy, the Vice President of the UNBA, BCU

Advocacy

«The Convention will enhance the quality of human protection from criminal prosecution», - Valentyn Gvozdiy, the Vic…

Recently, the Council of Europe adopted the Convention on the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer, an international treaty that guarantees the independence, security and self-governance of lawyers. The latter call it a key step towards strengthening the rule of law. But what does this mean in practice, why is the Convention of extraordinary value - these and other questions were answered by Valentyn Gvozdiy, the Vice President of the UNBA, BCU, to the host of Fakty ICTV.

11:41 Thu 20.03.25 258

Надішліть файл із текстом публікації у форматі *.doc, фотографію за тематикою у розмірі 640х400 та Ваше фото.

Оберіть файл