Fixed fee: time of work is important for reimbursement of attorney's fees – SC
The procedure for calculating the hourly fee differs from the fixed fee, which does not take into account the actual time spent. However, in both cases, they are taken into account when deciding on the reimbursement of legal aid expenses.
This was pointed out by the Commercial Court of Cassation of the Supreme Court in its additional resolution No. 910/12155/22 dated February 13, 2024, the text of which has recently appeared in the USRCD.
Having won the dispute in the cassation instance, the company asked the court to recover legal aid costs in the amount of UAH 18 thousand from its procedural opponent. The latter considered this amount to be excessive and filed a motion to reduce the legal fees to UAH 3 thousand.
Among the reasons for reducing the costs, he pointed out that the amount of costs was not commensurate with the complexity of the case and the work performed by the lawyers.
The high judges reminded that the main grounds and principles for reimbursement of legal aid costs are set out in paragraphs 7.1 - 7.9 of the resolution of the Supreme Court of Ukraine dated 05.07.2023 in case No. 911/3312/21. Also, the Supreme Court composed of judges of the Joint Chamber of the CGS considered the issue of expenses for the payment of attorney's fees in its resolutions of 02.02.2024 in case No. 910/9714/22 and of 03.11.2023 in case No. 914/2355/21.
According to part 4 of Art. 126 of the EPC, the amount of expenses for attorney's fees should be commensurate with:
1) the complexity of the case and the work performed by the attorney (services rendered);
2) the time spent by the advocate to perform the relevant work (services);
3) the scope of services rendered by the advocate and work performed;
4) the value of the claim and (or) the importance of the case for the party, including the impact of the case resolution on the reputation of the party or public interest in the case.
In case of non-compliance with these requirements, the court may, at the request of the other party, reduce the amount of costs. In this case the burden of proving disproportionality of expenses is on the party applying for their reduction.
In the case under consideration the fixed amount of the fee was established. In this case, the actual amount of time spent by the attorney in providing services to the client is not calculated. The amount of the fee is determined only by agreement between the advocate and the client, and the court has no right to interfere in these legal relations. At the same time, the obligations between the advocate and the client are not binding on the court in the context of deciding on the distribution of court costs.
Therefore, a party may prove the disproportionality of expenses, including, but not limited to, without specifying in the detailed description of the work (services rendered) information about the time spent on the provision of legal assistance. And taking into account the specific circumstances, the court may limit the amount, taking into account the reasonable necessity of court costs in the case.
Taking into account the disproportionality of the amount of the fixed fee to the complexity of the case, the price of the claim, the volume of materials in the case, the number of procedural documents prepared, and the number of meetings, the Supreme Court concluded that the claimed amount of compensation for expenses was excessive, and therefore awarded it partially in the amount of UAH 10 thousand.
Popular news
Advocacy
FLA needs urgent help, - Valentyn Gvozdiy
Twelve years of existence of the free legal aid system in Ukraine is enough to understand the inability of the Ministry of Justice to effectively manage this area.
Advocacy
The Ombudsman is concerned about the state of the FLA system
The Secretariat of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights is ready to join the development of proposals for amendments to the legal acts developed by the Ukrainian National Bar Association that will improve the functioning of the free legal aid system.
Advocacy
Ombudsman to provide legal aid with support of UNBA - pilot project
The Office of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights has launched a pilot project to provide professional legal aid to citizens in five regions of Ukraine.
Advocacy
Another model should be introduced for the FLA system, - Lidiya Izovitova
Monitoring of the current state of functioning of the legal aid system shows the existence of significant and conceptual problems in the implementation of this assistance in Ukraine.
Advocacy
Violation of media guarantees of advocacy is being studied by the UNBA
An open appeal of the Ukrainian National Bar Association's Committee on Information Policy and Interaction with the Mass Media to the advocates.
Advocacy
Lawyers are offered to be booked - amendments to draft law No. 10449
In their amendments to the draft law on strengthening mobilization, MPs propose to provide for the booking of lawyers. The goal is to prevent disruptions of court hearings.
Advocacy
E-Court failures violate constitutional guarantees – UNBA
In recent days, the Ukrainian National Bar Association has received numerous reports from lawyers about technical failures in the operation of the Electronic Court subsystem. In particular, the complaints relate to the inability to log in to the electronic office, which restricts advocates in exercising their procedural rights, in particular, to submit documents and participate in court hearings in the videoconference mode.
Advocacy
Fixed fee: time of work is important for reimbursement of attorney's fees – SC
The procedure for calculating the hourly fee differs from the fixed fee, which does not take into account the actual time spent. However, in both cases, they are taken into account when deciding on the reimbursement of legal aid expenses.
Publications
Ihor Kolesnykov A BRIEF SUMMARY REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDER ON EXTENDED CONFISCATION IN LATVIA REGARDING FINANCIAL ASSETS OF…
Valentyn Gvozdiy WORKING IN A WAR ZONE
Lydia Izovitova Formula of perfection
Sergiy Vylkov Our judicial system is so built that courts do not trust advocates
Iryna Vasylyk Advocacy in the proclamation of Independence of Ukraine
Oleksandr DULSKY When we cross the border of the Supreme Anti-Corruption Court, we get into another department of the National Anti-Corruption…
Vadym Krasnyk The UNBA will work, and all obstacles and restrictions are only temporary inconveniences
Lydia Izovitova Interview with Lydia Izovitova on the occasion of the 8th anniversary of the founding of UNBA: We are the voice of t…