Methodology for calculating episodes when paying for FLA lawyer's services should be clarified, - BCU
The Bar Council of Ukraine is initiating changes to the Cabinet of Ministers' resolution on payment for services and reimbursement of expenses of lawyers providing free secondary legal aid.
The relevant decision was made at the last meeting of the UNBA following the discussion of the appeal of a lawyer who complained about the unfairness of the payment formula used by regional FLA centers (Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 465 of 17.09.2014).
The lawyer submitted to the center an act of services rendered and a calculation of the amount of remuneration in criminal proceedings at the stage of pre-trial investigation, taking into account ten episodes of offenses. However, officials determined that the calculation should be based on only two episodes.
According to the resolution, the severity of the alleged crime for each episode is taken into account when determining the amount of payment. One of the crimes the person was suspected of committing was the illegal sale of psychotropic substances. Each of the episodes of the violation was registered in the URPTI, as the facts of the sale were characterized by a separate time, place, and method of commission and had their own subject of proof. In addition, each fact was a separate sufficient ground for bringing a person to justice. But the center decided that it was a continuing offense. And according to the rules, if the offense is treated as a continuing offense in the proceedings, it is taken as one episode when calculating the reward.
«This position, in the reasonable opinion of the Committee, is unfair, - said Oksana Kadenko, a member of the BCU, chairman of the UNBA Committee on Legal Aid, during the meeting. - After all, it does not take into account the scope of work of a lawyer in the defense of a person... This, accordingly, is a completely different scope of research of evidence, work with a client, research of materials, formation of a position, etc. The assessment of this situation clearly does not meet the goal of differentiating the payment of attorneys' fees depending on the scope of services provided».
She drew attention to the fact that if the lawyer had agreed to the qualification with a sign of repetition, the issue would have been resolved, but such formalization of the indictment directly contradicts the interests of the client, because this sign of repetition aggravates criminal liability.
The participants of the meeting agreed that the problem does exist. And Barbara Kalyuzhna, a member of the BCU, additionally pointed out that a similar situation is associated with the representation of several victims, when, despite the significant volume, payment is made as if for work with one victim.
In the end, the UNBA stated the need to amend the calculation methodology and proposed to introduce three criteria in the context of remuneration of lawyers: the number of episodes according to the extracts from the URPTI, the number of episodes according to the indictment and the number of episodes according to the verdict of the court of first instance. At the same time, the largest of the three indicators should be used to pay for the work of a lawyer.
Popular news
Legislation
Proceedings against military personnel following AWOL require clear deadlines — UNBA
A soldier’s return to duty after AWOL does not necessarily mean the end of criminal proceedings. To ensure that the case does not remain at the pretrial investigation stage, a clear procedure for the investigator and prosecutor is required.
Legislation
The UNBA warned of the risk of customs barriers for Ukrainian paper and furniture
Ukraine’s anti-deforestation rules are intended to preserve export access to the EU market. However, without paper and furniture on the list of goods, without effective sanctions, and with enforcement beginning only in 2030, these rules could hinder that goal.
Legislation
Fines for loud exhaust — based on a standardized measurement method — UNBA
Measures to combat intentionally loud exhaust noises are justified, especially during wartime. However, as long as the law does not specify which noise standard to apply or how to measure it on the road, this new liability can be neither fair nor effective.
Guarantees of the practice of law
Guarantees for advocacy without protective measures: proposed changes to the codes
The current law sets forth the rights and guarantees of the legal profession, but lacks the tools to protect them. The future law on advocacy is intended to fill this gap through amendments to criminal, administrative and procedural legislation.
Abroad
Living abroad doesn't sever your ties with Ukraine: what you should check
Moving to another country and even long-term residence abroad does not automatically sever an individual’s legal ties to Ukraine. Tax residency, sole proprietorship status, foreign income, enforcement proceedings, and military registration remain relevant even after relocation.
Legislation
Exceptions to the state prosecutor's representation in court must be consistent with the CCU's decision
To prevent the provisions of Article 23 of the Law «On the prosecutor’s office» from being declared unconstitutional again, the proposed amendments contained in the government’s draft law should be clarified.
Educational events
How can an advocate defend a client whose data is processed by the Interpol system?
The absence of a last name on the Interpol website does not necessarily mean that no one is looking for that person. How can you find out exactly what information police databases in 196 countries hold about a client, and does the removal of a record mean that the problems are behind you?
Legislation
A bill implementing the Convention on the Protection of the Professions of Lawyer has been introduced
The constitutional guarantees of legal aid, defense, and the independence of advocacy cannot be realized without protecting advocates from unwarranted interference in their professional activities, including searches, the seizure of professional materials and the use of criminal procedural mechanisms to exert pressure.
Publications
Vasyl Kolishnyi, «Law and Business» Supporting mental health should become part of the professional culture of the Bar, - H. Udovenko
Volodymyr Matsko Extradition during wartime: when the risks outweigh the request
Volodymyr Matsko Extradition as a systemic form of rights violations
Victoria Yakusha, Law and Business The anti-corruption vertical cannot «take care» of the Bar as an institution, - acting head of the HQDCB
Censor.net Protecting advocates – protecting justice: addressing concerns about the new law
Ihor Kolesnykov A BRIEF SUMMARY REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDER ON EXTENDED CONFISCATION IN LATVIA REGARDING FINANCIAL ASSETS OF…
Valentyn Gvozdiy WORKING IN A WAR ZONE
Lydia Izovitova Formula of perfection
