When courts ignore the guarantee of free choice of defense counsel

Advocacy
15:32 Tue 26.03.24 477 Reviews
Print

If the defense in criminal proceedings is successful, the prosecution sometimes tries to «replace» the defense counsel in certain procedural actions with the support of the court. For this purpose, lawyers from the FLA system are appointed.

The abuses related to the involvement of a lawyer for a separate procedural action were analyzed in the Report on topical issues of the functioning of the free legal aid system in Ukraine. The UNBA presented the document on March 19.

The institute of appointing a lawyer to participate in a separate procedural action is currently one of the most powerful mechanisms for violating the right to defense and equality of the parties to criminal proceedings.

The Constitution of Ukraine provides for a guarantee of free choice of defense counsel for every person (Article 59). At the same time, according to part 1 of Article 53 of the CPC, the investigator, prosecutor, investigating judge or court has the right to engage a defense counsel to conduct a separate procedural action. But only in urgent cases, when there is a need to conduct an urgent procedural action with the participation of a defense counsel, and the previously notified defense counsel cannot arrive to participate in the procedural action or ensure the participation of another defense counsel, or if the suspect or accused has expressed a desire but has not yet had time to engage a defense counsel or the arrival of the chosen defense counsel is impossible. The problem is that the law does not define what kind of action should be considered urgent. It is also an open question whether the validity of the reasons for the defense counsel's absence affects the application of the mechanism of engaging a defense counsel.

«The courts, knowing that their ruling on the engagement of a defense lawyer is binding, use their powers too broadly, - says Olena Demyanova, secretary of the UNBA Legal Aid Committee. - And a whole arsenal of abuses has already been formed in the context of considering the extension of the term of detention».

She said that in order to engage a lawyer from the FLA system, the court sets the time for consideration of the relevant petition without agreeing with the contracted defense counsel. For this purpose, sometimes the time is selected in such a way that the defense counsel is busy with other cases. At the same time, the deadlines for proper notification of the defense are not met. This is evidenced by existing complaints from lawyers who report that in this way the prosecution, with the assistance of the court, is trying to eliminate inconvenient lawyers.

There are also blatant cases when the investigator tries to involve a FLA lawyer in familiarizing himself with the criminal proceedings, or the court - to participate in court debates.

«In such cases, the suspect or accused is usually hostile to the appointed lawyer. The person does not want to work with him or her because they already have their own defense lawyer and are satisfied with his or her work. The latter is also concerned about the situation, because the defense strategy is breaking down. And the court and the prosecution insist on the participation of a FLA lawyer. So he finds himself in an extremely uncomfortable position, - explains O. Demyanova. - And we receive a large number of complaints and appeals about this».

The main way to solve the problem is to improve legislation. At the same time, joint activities with representatives of the judiciary are possible to develop a common understanding of the rules.

Popular news

The process of signing the Convention on the protection of the profession of advocate was taken under control by the Verkhovna Rada

Guarantees of the practice of law

The process of signing the Convention on the protection of the profession of advocate was taken under control by t…

The Ministry of Justice sent the text of the translation of the Council of Europe Convention on the protection of the advocate to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs «for review and approval». The main legal authority also expressed its support for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs regarding the signing and ratification of this Convention.

16:49 Wed 03.09.25 136
Statement by the UNBA Committee on the «National Police investigation»

Guarantees of the practice of law

Statement by the UNBA Committee on the «National Police investigation»

The media is spreading news that the National Police of Ukraine is allegedly investigating a criminal offense committed by the leadership of the Ukrainian National Bar Association.

13:35 Wed 03.09.25 108
Without the protection of advocates, there will be no fair trials in Ukraine — forum in Odesa

Discussion

Without the protection of advocates, there will be no fair trials in Ukraine — forum in Odesa

Identifying an advocate with their client undermines the foundations of justice, as it deprives individuals of the opportunity to exercise their right to defense, forces advocates to avoid participating in high-profile cases, and ultimately renders procedural guarantees meaningless. Without this, fair trial is impossible.

14:42 Fri 29.08.25 114
The number of cases where advocates are identified with their clients is growing – UNBA report

Guarantees of the practice of law

The number of cases where advocates are identified with their clients is growing – UNBA report

Advocates are increasingly being held hostage to political processes, with them being equated with their clients. Such actions undermine the independence of the profession and create an atmosphere of intimidation, as a result of which Ukrainian citizens are deprived of their right to defense.

13:19 Thu 28.08.25 111
What data is sufficient to initiate an investigation – UNBA comments on draft law No. 12439

Legislation

What data is sufficient to initiate an investigation – UNBA comments on draft law No. 12439

The problem of law enforcement pressure on business remains one of the most acute for the Ukrainian economy. The lack of regulation of certain procedures in the Criminal Procedure Code leads to abuses, as a result of which entrepreneurs find themselves in a state of legal uncertainty.

19:41 Fri 22.08.25 116
Law on advocacy and the Council of Europe Convention: the UNBA assessed compliance (comparative table)

Guarantees of the practice of law

Law on advocacy and the Council of Europe Convention: the UNBA assessed compliance (comparative table)

The Ukrainian National Bar Association has prepared and published a comparative table showing the extent to which Ukrainian legislation complies with the provisions of the Council of Europe Convention on the protection of the profession of advocate.

14:58 Fri 22.08.25 114
The Verkhovna Rada is waiting for the Minister of Justice to take action on signing the Convention on the protection of the profession of advocate

Guarantees of the practice of law

The Verkhovna Rada is waiting for the Minister of Justice to take action on signing the Convention on the protection of t…

Ukraine, which was directly involved in the preparation of the world's first Council of Europe Convention on the protection of the profession of advocate, has still not signed it. There appear to be no formal objections, but no real steps have been taken towards accession either.

13:51 Thu 21.08.25 150
Australian advocate apologizes in court for fake AI quotes

Abroad

Australian advocate apologizes in court for fake AI quotes

In Australia, a royal advocate apologized to a judge for submitting documents in a criminal case against a teenager accused of murder that contained fabricated quotes and non-existent court decisions generated by artificial intelligence.

13:46 Tue 19.08.25 119

Надішліть файл із текстом публікації у форматі *.doc, фотографію за тематикою у розмірі 640х400 та Ваше фото.

Оберіть файл