Beating of a lawyer in Kharkiv: what is known about the incident in the premises of the MME

When the lawyer began to record violations of her client's rights in the premises of the military medical commission, the defender was pushed out of the room by physical force and her belongings were thrown away. The Verkhovna Rada became interested in the incident, and the Ombudsman took the case under his personal control.
On January 9, Yulia Palagina, who provided professional legal assistance to a person liable for military service, arrived at the premises of the MME. The day before, her client was detained in the Shevchenkivskyi District Territorial Center for Recruitment and Social Support in Kharkiv and forced to undergo a medical examination. So the lawyer was looking for evidence of the examination. Initially, she was informed that the person had already undergone a medical examination, was found fit for military service and sent back to the TCC for further mobilization. However, no documentary evidence was provided.
Since the man's whereabouts were unknown, the lawyer called the police to document the violation of the procedure. But immediately afterwards, a man in military uniform, who had previously checked Yulia Palagina's documents and credentials, ordered her to leave the premises.
«I refused, explaining that I was on the territory of a civilian hospital waiting for the police. In response, this man said (literally): «Either come out nice or it will be bad». I asked him what I meant by that, and he grabbed me and began to force me out of the room. It is clear that I was defending myself. And the more actively I defended myself, the more aggressive he became and struck harder... After pushing me out of the room, they kept my belongings and documents containing the attorney-client privilege... Only after a while one of them opened the door and threw my things on the floor», - the lawyer told about the incident. - All this was happening in front of the medical staff and visitors of the hospital, who tried to call the offender to reason.
Later, the police did arrive at the scene and the crime was registered in the Unified Register of Pre-trial Investigations. Palagina also appealed to the Bar Council of Kharkiv Region and the Committee for the Protection of Lawyers' Rights, and the examination confirmed the existence of bodily injuries.
«The servicemen of the Shevchenkivskyi RTCC and SS violated the right to personal inviolability guaranteed by the Constitution of Ukraine, violated the rights and guarantees of the practice of law guaranteed by the Law on the Bar and Practice of Law», - the representatives of the Kharkiv Regional Bar Council assessed the incident in a video.
The bar self-government body reported that eyewitnesses to the incident had already been interviewed. And they gave positive information about the professional, ethical behavior of the advocate, who acted within the framework of the concluded agreement using the rights to file petitions, applications, appeals and obtain information about his client. There were no provocative or other actions that could be qualified as going beyond the limits of the advocate's ethical behavior.
The advocate informed the persons in military uniforms about her procedural status, providing them with her ID and informing them of her powers in relation to her client. In response, physical force was used against Yulia Palagina. She was pushed out of the room, hit in the torso and head, disrespected both her personality and professional affiliation, used both physical force and resorted to humiliation of the honor and dignity of the person, used sexist statements that humiliated the professional due to her being a woman, the SAR explained. «The only fair conclusion to this story is a verdict», - said Viktoria Gaivoronska, head of the Kharkiv Regional Bar Council.
In connection with the incident, MP Viktoriia Kinzburska appealed to the Main Department of the National Police in Kharkiv Region, the Territorial Department of the State Bureau of Investigation, the Head of the Specialized Defense Prosecutor's Office in the Eastern Region, and the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights. The MP draws attention to a gross violation of a number of rights guaranteed by the Constitution of Ukraine, in particular: the constitutional right to professional legal assistance, which, in accordance with the Law of Ukraine «On the Bar and Practice of Law», Y. Palagina tried to provide to her client, as well as her constitutional right to personal inviolability.
The Ombudsman immediately responded to the situation: «I am grateful for the appeal. I am aware of this situation, it is already in progress. The relevant letters have been sent. I am taking it under my personal control», - said Dmytro Lubinets.
According to available information, the investigation is currently underway.
Popular news

Advocacy
The BCU defended 36 lawyers accused by the TCC of disrupting mobilization
The actions of the lawyers described in the appeal of the Bucha District Territorial Center for Recruitment and Social Support as unlawful offenses are in fact the exercise of legal powers related to the provision of professional legal assistance to clients - citizens of Ukraine who are liable for military service.

Advocacy
Parliamentary instruments should not be used for private interests - statement of crime
Law enforcement agencies should assess whether an MP is using the parliamentary research tool in private interests. Involvement of the Research Service of the Verkhovna Rada in tasks not provided for in its Regulations has signs of corruption.

Advocacy
Advocates and forensic experts join forces: plans for cooperation discussed
At the National Scientific Center «Bokarius Institute of Forensic Expertise» of the Ministry of Justice, a working meeting was held between the management of this expert institution and Lidiya Izovitova, the President of the National Bar Association of Ukraine, the Bar Council of Ukraine.

Advocacy
The Constitution is the same in TCCs and outside them, - the Secretary of the BCU on the rules for lawyers
The Land Forces of the Armed Forces of Ukraine are working to eliminate shortcomings in the work of territorial recruitment and social support centers. In particular, they want to create rules for lawyers who defend people liable for military service.

Advocacy
5 more advocates received financial support from the UNBA Board of Trustees
On January 28, 2025, the UNBA Board of Trustees held its first meeting of the year. The Board considered 8 applications from advocates who found themselves in difficult life circumstances due to the war.

Advocacy
Mental health support for lawyers will be put on a platform
The project to support the mental health of Ukrainian lawyers during the war, implemented by the Ukrainian National Bar Association with the support of the International Bar Association (IBA), will get its own electronic platform.

Advocacy
Legal aid during mobilization: TCC sees no problems
The military authorities claim that the training center or distribution center is not a place of detention. There is normal (taking into account the regime) access, including for lawyers. But practice shows the opposite.

Advocacy
Beating of a lawyer in Kharkiv: what is known about the incident in the premises of the MME
When the lawyer began to record violations of her client's rights in the premises of the military medical commission, the defender was pushed out of the room by physical force and her belongings were thrown away. The Verkhovna Rada became interested in the incident, and the Ombudsman took the case under his personal control.
Publications

Ihor Kolesnykov A BRIEF SUMMARY REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDER ON EXTENDED CONFISCATION IN LATVIA REGARDING FINANCIAL ASSETS OF…

Valentyn Gvozdiy WORKING IN A WAR ZONE

Lydia Izovitova Formula of perfection

Sergiy Vylkov Our judicial system is so built that courts do not trust advocates

Iryna Vasylyk Advocacy in the proclamation of Independence of Ukraine

Oleksandr DULSKY When we cross the border of the Supreme Anti-Corruption Court, we get into another department of the National Anti-Corruption…

Vadym Krasnyk The UNBA will work, and all obstacles and restrictions are only temporary inconveniences

Lydia Izovitova Interview with Lydia Izovitova on the occasion of the 8th anniversary of the founding of UNBA: We are the voice of t…