European Presidents Conference 2025: Challenges to the Rule of Law by Lidiya Izovitova

Advocacy
17:41 Mon 03.03.25 494 Reviews
Print

Against the backdrop of the war in Ukraine and the discussion of guarantees of its security, there is a growing militarization of political discourse not only in Ukraine but also in European countries. In the context of martial law, the issue of reforming the military justice system, including the possibility of creating an institute of military advocacy, has become particularly relevant.

Lidiya Izovitova, the President of the UNBA, BCU, drew attention to this in her speech at the 53rd European Presidents Conference, which took place in Vienna on February 27-March 1.

The Ukrainian delegation at the event was also represented by Valentyn Gvozdiy, the Vice President of the UNBA, BCU, Ihor Kolesnikov, Secretary of the BCU, and Hanna Lazarchuk, the UNBA member from Rivne region.

The President of the UNBA, BCU reminded the conference participants that today in Ukraine, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court emphasizes the need to amend the Constitution to establish military justice, including military courts, military public prosecution and the institute of military lawyers. This, in his opinion, will ensure an appropriate level of professionalism in the implementation of legal protection of military personnel.

The President of the UNBA, BCU also said that one of the territorial recruitment centers accused 36 Ukrainian lawyers of unlawful actions to disrupt the mobilization process and create conditions for evading the draft. In response, the Bar Council of Ukraine issued a statement that such actions were in fact the exercise of their legal authority to provide professional legal assistance to clients who are Ukrainian citizens subject to military service. And such pressure on lawyers by the military authorities (even without the creation of a military bar) is a telling example of potential threats in the future.

So the question arises: will the military bar be able to protect the interests of military personnel and military lawyers themselves? The answer is definitely no.

Moreover, the consequence will be a weakening of the guarantees of the practice of law and the independence of the bar through the introduction of the principles of military service. This is because subordination to the military command makes it impossible for an advocate to perform his or her professional duties independently. Moreover, this directly contradicts international standards of legal independence, in particular the UN Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers and international standards of justice.

The UNBA believes that an alternative solution should be to strengthen legal guarantees for lawyers who defend military personnel without creating a separate military institute of the Bar.

Taking this opportunity, L. Izovitova also addressed the presidents of the European bar associations present in the conference hall and expressed her deep gratitude for the broad support and invaluable assistance provided in difficult times for Ukraine.

However, the initiative to create a military bar as a separate institution is worrisome, as it could lead to the abolition of established professional standards and pose a threat to the independence of human rights activities and the effective enforcement of the rights of servicemen.

L. Izovitova explained that the key threat is the risk of losing the independence of lawyers who will work in this structure. After all, military service is based on principles (centralization, subordination and unquestioning execution of orders) that contradict the fundamental principles of the independence of the bar and the rule of law (independence, professional autonomy and the priority of human rights).

And the principle of unity of command enshrines the decision-making powers of commanders, which creates a risk of influence on lawyers who may be subjected to administrative or disciplinary pressure. Therefore, the introduction of military governance standards in the field of advocacy will inevitably affect its independence. This may not only undermine the foundations of the legal profession, but also create risks of violating the rights of military personnel whom the lawyer is supposed to protect.

Popular news

The model for legal assistance to veterans was discussed at the UNBA

Legal defence of military personnel

The model for legal assistance to veterans was discussed at the UNBA

A working meeting was held at the Ukrainian National Bar Association, during which representatives of the advocacy profession, the Ministry of Veterans Affairs of Ukraine and a foreign expert discussed approaches to providing legal aid to veterans, the role of the advocacy profession in this system, and the experience of other countries.

18:07 Mon 20.04.26 105
The CJU has endorsed guarantees of the legal profession’s independence and has proposed a meeting with the BCU

Guarantees of the practice of law

The CJU has endorsed guarantees of the legal profession’s independence and has proposed a meeting with the BCU

The Council of Judges of Ukraine has responded to a letter from the Bar Council of Ukraine regarding the inadmissibility of the High Council of Justice granting immunity to a member of the High Council of Justice — a privilege not provided for by law — as well as regarding violations of constitutional guarantees of the independence of the legal profession and attorney-client privilege.

18:24 Fri 17.04.26 103
The UNBA and the Ministry of Veterans are expanding their cooperation

Interaction

The UNBA and the Ministry of Veterans are expanding their cooperation

War veterans, their family members, as well as the family members of fallen Defenders of Ukraine are to receive improved access to professional legal assistance and additional opportunities for independent legal protection.

16:27 Mon 13.04.26 124
Advocates have warned that the draft Labor Code would curtail workers' protections

Legislation

Advocates have warned that the draft Labor Code would curtail workers' protections

Certain provisions of the draft Labor Code of Ukraine regarding collective labor disputes undermine labor protections and do not comply with constitutional and international standards.

11:47 Thu 09.04.26 210
Representatives from the Ministry of Veterans Affairs and the UNBA discussed veterans' access to justice

Legal defence of military personnel

Representatives from the Ministry of Veterans Affairs and the UNBA discussed veterans' access to justice

On April 3, a working meeting was held at the Ministry of Veterans Affairs of Ukraine with representatives of the Ukrainian National Bar Association, dedicated to improving the effectiveness of legal protection for war veterans and their families.

16:17 Tue 07.04.26 154
The right of minors to marry: how judicial oversight works

Educational events

The right of minors to marry: how judicial oversight works

The issue of granting minors the right to marry lies at the intersection of family law, child protection, and judicial discretion. The UNBA Committee on family law dedicated a webinar held on March 30 to this very topic.

11:28 Tue 07.04.26 184
The UNBA and the Coordination headquarters have agreed to cooperate in assisting those released from captivity

Interaction

The UNBA and the Coordination headquarters have agreed to cooperate in assisting those released from captivity

Servicemen released from captivity, family members of prisoners of war, civilians deprived of their personal liberty as a result of armed aggression, as well as persons missing in connection with the war, will gain additional opportunities to access legal assistance and protect their rights.

19:14 Mon 06.04.26 167
BCU: The HCJ’s decisions undermine the constitutional guarantees of the independence of the advocacy profession

Self-government

BCU: The HCJ’s decisions undermine the constitutional guarantees of the independence of the advocacy profession

The Bar Council of Ukraine has concluded that, in its recent decisions, the High Council of Justice has, without legal grounds, called into question the right of bar self-governing bodies to protect the guarantees of legal practice and has, in effect, attempted to grant one of its members — who retains the status of an advocate — special immunity from the Rules of professional conduct and disciplinary responsibility.

14:56 Thu 02.04.26 208

Надішліть файл із текстом публікації у форматі *.doc, фотографію за тематикою у розмірі 640х400 та Ваше фото.

Оберіть файл