ICJ report: Lawyers in Ukraine continue to be regularly targeted through the justice system for undue reasons
Lawyers in Ukraine continue to be regularly targeted through the justice system for undue reasons. They continue to be identified with their clients, facing negative consequences not only at the hands of violent extremist right-wing radical groups, but also as a result of abuse of legal proceedings against them.
This is stated in particular in the report of the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) called «Between the Rock and the Anvil: Lawyers under Attack in Ukraine» issued following ICJ one-week mission to Ukraine from 4 to 8 March 2019 to assess the situation of security and independence of lawyers.
The report presents conclusions and recommendations on the safety of lawyers, murders, harassment of lawyers through the use of legal mechanisms, problems faced by lawyers in defending human rights, independence and reform of the bar in Ukraine, the work of lawyers in uncontrolled territories.
The ICJ, in particular, noted that the conflict of 2014 has significantly affected the justice system and individual lawyers have found themselves at the front-line of the conflict or its ideological aftermath in one form or another. While not every lawyer’s work was affected, those who work on politically sensitive cases have faced attacks and harassment, and in some cases have been killed This cannot but send a strong signal to all lawyers of the consequences they may face for a zealous defence of the clients and has a chilling effect on work of the legal profession.
The report stressed that political endorsement of violent extreme right-wing groups operating in the name of patriotism has resulted in weakening of the rule of law and a significant level of impunity for carrying out attacks on lawyers. Not only lawyers, but judges as well as the justice system as a whole have been undermined by the regular and frequent attacks and impunity for them. Lawyers have often been left alone and without effective legal recourse against groups who intimidate, threaten, attack or otherwise harass them and interfere with their professional activity. The greatest irreparable consequences of such attacks are killings of lawyers for which the perpetrators have not been brought to justice.
The ICJ acknowledged and commended that the UNBA plays an active role in monitoring these cases, though little has been done to speedily and fully investigate them.
We recall that in March 2019, the UNBA leadership met with a delegation of the International Commission of Jurists during their mission in Ukraine. The topic of the meeting was the observance of the rights of lawyers in Ukraine. In this regard, the reasons for the appearance of the draft law No. 9055 «On the Bar and Legal Practice» were discussed, as well as the threats to lawyers to provide effective protection, provide legal assistance to all citizens of Ukraine, the existence of independent legal self-government.
Popular news
Practice of law
BCU strengthens its position on the right of advocate to prioritize cases
In legal practice, it is not uncommon for court hearings in different cases to be scheduled at the same time. This raises the question: which case should the advocate attend first, and can the court interfere with this decision?
Edition
Advocate or lobbyist? The UNBA has presented a guide to distinguishing between the professions
The Ukrainian National Bar Association has prepared a guide that helps distinguish between the legal status of an advocate and a lobbyist, explains the limits of permissible activities for each, and prevents possible violations of ethical and legal standards when participating in public policy-making.
Announcements
Essay contest on the synergy of human and artificial intelligence in diplomacy has begun
The Educational and Scientific Institute of International Relations at Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv invites students from higher education institutions in Ukraine to participate in the Second All-Ukrainian essay competition on the topic «Modern Ukrainian diplomacy: synergy of human and artificial intelligence in defending national interests».
Abroad
Where is the line between respect for the court and the dignity of an advocate?
Ukrainian advocates sometimes complain about condescending attitudes or tactless remarks from judges. But such conflicts are not unique to Ukraine. In various countries, advocates raise issues of communication culture in court, mutual respect, and the inadmissibility of humiliating participants.
Discussion
Occupational safety during wartime: legal risks and employer liability
On October 21, the National Bar Association of Ukraine held a round table discussion on «Occupational safety in conditions of martial law». Participants discussed how the war has changed the requirements for safe working conditions, what guarantees remain for employees, and what responsibility employers bear for violations of legislation in this area.
Abroad
The Czech advocacy has spoken out in defense of the professional independence of its Ukrainian colleagues
The Czech Bar Association (Česká advokátní komora, ČAK) will appeal to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Ukrainian authorities to ensure the preservation of the independence of advocacy in Ukraine.
Legal defence of military personnel
When agreement is (im)possible: family disputes involving military personnel
The number of family cases involving military personnel is growing, with the most common issues being divorce, division of joint property, alimony, deprivation or contestation of parental rights, adoption, establishment of guardianship, and cases related to domestic violence.
Self-government
Marina Stavniychuk: The UNBA is a professional organization, not a monopoly
A unitary state requires uniform standards for access to the profession and disciplinary responsibility, which is why the Ukrainian National Bar Association acts as a professional organization. Accusations of monopoly are false, because public associations cannot replace professional self-government.
Publications
Censor.net Protecting advocates – protecting justice: addressing concerns about the new law
Ihor Kolesnykov A BRIEF SUMMARY REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDER ON EXTENDED CONFISCATION IN LATVIA REGARDING FINANCIAL ASSETS OF…
Valentyn Gvozdiy WORKING IN A WAR ZONE
Lydia Izovitova Formula of perfection
Sergiy Vylkov Our judicial system is so built that courts do not trust advocates
Iryna Vasylyk Advocacy in the proclamation of Independence of Ukraine
Oleksandr DULSKY When we cross the border of the Supreme Anti-Corruption Court, we get into another department of the National Anti-Corruption…
Vadym Krasnyk The UNBA will work, and all obstacles and restrictions are only temporary inconveniences
