Regarding the NACP's Pressure on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine: Statement of the Bar Council of Ukraine

Advocacy
12:47 Wed 12.06.24 340 Reviews
Print

On June 11, the National Agency for the Prevention of Corruption published a news item on its website entitled «Should members of the Qualification and Disciplinary Commissions of the Bar Declare: Whose Side Will the CCU Take?», in which it called on the public, journalists and international partners to closely monitor the consideration by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of the complaint filed by Oksana Bukhtoyarova, a member of the Disciplinary Chamber of the Qualification and Disciplinary Commission of the Bar of the Zakarpattia Region, regarding the constitutionality of certain provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Prevention of Corruption». The CCU hearing on this case is scheduled to take place at 10 a.m. on June 12, 2024.

Along with presenting the agency's position on the impossibility of satisfying the constitutional complaint, Deputy Head of the NACP Yaroslav Lyubchenko stated that members of the High Qualification and Disciplinary Commission and members of the disciplinary chambers of the QDCB, who decide on the disciplinary responsibility of current lawyers, must submit declarations. He stated that there are very high corruption risks in this area, and the positions of the commission members have a high level of influence and, at the same time, discretion without clear criteria for its application.

The Ukrainian National Bar Association has repeatedly expressed its position on the issue raised in the constitutional complaint of O. Bukhtoyarova in forms that respect both the status of the Constitutional Court and the principles of constitutional justice.

Taking into account the provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine and the Law of Ukraine «On the Constitutional Court of Ukraine», the Bar Council of Ukraine:

  • assesses the public statements of the NACP leadership, as well as the fact of placing the publication immediately before the session of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, as a manifestation of direct pressure on the judges of the only body of constitutional jurisdiction;
  • draws attention to the fact that a judge of the Constitutional Court exercises his/her powers exclusively under the Constitution of Ukraine and the Law of Ukraine «On the Constitutional Court of Ukraine», based on the rule of law. Influencing a judge of the Constitutional Court in any way is prohibited (Article 24 of the Law of Ukraine «On the Constitutional Court of Ukraine»);
  • notes that the Constitutional Court a priori cannot «take sides», as the NACP formulates the issue in its statement of June 11. After all, the Constitutional Court is not a court of facts, but a court of law! The body of constitutional jurisdiction decides on the compliance of the laws of Ukraine with the Constitution of Ukraine and provides official interpretation of the Constitution of Ukraine. Putting the question in the format of «whose side will the CCU take» may indicate a high level of legal nihilism in the approaches to the NACP's activities, which denies the social value of law - the basis of the Constitutional Court's activities;
  • reminds us that a constitutional complaint is the newest guarantee of protection of citizens' rights. And the accusatory bias demonstrated in the NAPC's publication shows a lack of understanding of the European legal culture at a time when Ukraine is at the beginning of negotiations on accession to the EU, where the rule of law is a key value.
  • expresses its belief that the Constitutional Court, despite the fact of pressure, adheres to the requirements of Article 147 of the Basic Law of Ukraine, according to which the activities of the Constitutional Court should be based on the principles of the rule of law, independence, collegiality, transparency, validity and binding nature of its decisions and conclusions.

Popular news

Advocacy

UNBA to file criminal complaints about violations of advocates' rights

Recently, the UNBA has received more frequent appeals about violations of the rights of lawyers and guarantees of the practice of law. Including by employees of the territorial centers of recruitment and social support. Some of the facts contain signs of a crime.

17:38 Thu 26.09.24 134

Advocacy

An extract from the URAU will be available in your personal account

Starting Monday, September 23, lawyers will be able to independently generate extracts from the Unified Register of Advocates of Ukraine through their personal electronic account on the website of the Ukrainian National Bar Association.

19:23 Fri 20.09.24 106

Advocacy

A Register of Administrative Proceedings on Lawyers' Complaints to Be Established in Ukraine

All cases of unlawful refusal to provide information at the request of lawyers, the requests of the QDCB, their chambers or members will be recorded in the Register of applications (appeals) on administrative offenses. The relevant terms of reference have already been submitted to the IT service for implementation.

18:49 Fri 20.09.24 110

Advocacy

The shadow report on justice will be evaluated at the BCU

Recently, the so-called Shadow Report to the Justice and Fundamental Rights section of the European Commission's Report on Ukraine was published, prepared by a coalition of NGOs led by the Agency for Legislative Initiatives with the support of the European Union's Pravo-Justice Project and other NGOs.

18:13 Fri 20.09.24 109

Advocacy

Ukraine on the way to the OECD: the Bar contributes to the implementation of the program

Accession to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development is a common challenge for all national institutions, on which the European future of the state depends. The Bar contributes to the implementation of the relevant OECD Program for Ukraine.

13:23 Wed 18.09.24 117

Advocacy

The work on the Convention on the Protection of the Legal Profession has been completed

The Council of Europe has prepared the final text of the draft Convention on the Protection of the Legal Profession, the world's first document that sets international standards for the protection of lawyers, guarantees their independence and protects them from risks associated with the performance of their professional duties.

11:27 Fri 13.09.24 113

Advocacy

The UNBA is studying additional opportunities to support advocates

The full-scale invasion has seriously affected the mental health of all Ukrainians. There are certain vulnerable groups that have been most affected by the war in their personal and professional lives, including lawyers.

17:57 Tue 10.09.24 163

Advocacy

Everyone deserves protection, the Bar fulfills this requirement of the Constitution

The formation of the opinion in society that lawyers somehow choose their clients incorrectly because some people are not worthy of defense is a very dangerous phenomenon for the state. In the future, our enemies can use it against Ukraine.

13:44 Tue 27.08.24 201

Надішліть файл із текстом публікації у форматі *.doc, фотографію за тематикою у розмірі 640х400 та Ваше фото.

Оберіть файл