Deserters will be released from liability under two conditions
The legislative initiative to introduce mechanisms for exempting members of the Armed Forces from criminal liability for committing a military criminal offense deserves support. At the same time, it contains controversial provisions.
This was noted by the UNBA Committee on Criminal Law and Procedure following the analysis of the draft Law No. 11322 dated 06.06.2024 «On Amendments to the Criminal Code of Ukraine, the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and Other Legislative Acts of Ukraine on Improving Criminal Liability for Crimes Against the Established Procedure for Performing or Completing Military Service during Martial Law».
In particular, the document proposes to supplement Article 401 of the CPC with conditions under which a person who first committed a crime under Article 407 (unauthorized leaving of a military unit or place of service) or Article 408 (desertion) of the Criminal Code may be released from criminal liability:
1) before the end of the pre-trial investigation, the person voluntarily informed the investigator or prosecutor of his/her intention to return to the military unit or place of service to continue military service;
2) the commander (chief) of the military unit (institution) has agreed to the continuation of military service by such person.
If these grounds are present, the prosecutor will have to obtain a written consent of the commander (chief) of the military unit (institution) on the possibility of continuing the military service of the suspect.
Taking into account the provisions of Article 44 of the Criminal Code, the UNBA believes that the wording of the provision «a person may be released from criminal liability» should be replaced with «a person is released from criminal liability».
Also, a person's consent to continue military service must be the result of a positive assessment by the commander of the person's previous performance in the position. However, if the consent can be granted by the commander (chief) of any military unit (institution), the possibility of achieving the goal of the draft law is doubtful. In addition, this approach contains corruption factors.
The full comments and suggestions of the UNBA to the draft law No. 11322 can be found at the link.
Popular news
Legislation
A bill implementing the Convention on the Protection of the Professions of Lawyer has been introduced
The constitutional guarantees of legal aid, defense, and the independence of advocacy cannot be realized without protecting advocates from unwarranted interference in their professional activities, including searches, the seizure of professional materials and the use of criminal procedural mechanisms to exert pressure.
Abroad
The CCBE is discussing European justice and issues related to the protection of advocates
Today, October 2, a meeting of the Standing Committee of the Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe (CCBE) is taking place in Brussels. On the agenda are the protection of the advocate profession, the rule of law, attorney-client privilege, and changes in the European justice system.
Rule of Law Roadmap
The UNBA presented the key provisions of the future law on advocacy in Brussels
The Ukrainian National Bar Association presented its proposals for the upcoming law on advocacy, aligned with the Rule of Law Roadmap. The presentation covered topics such as access to the profession, self-governance, disciplinary procedures, professional development and guarantees for the practice of advocacy.
Educational events
Advocates were taught to voice their complaints without making accusations
In a difficult conversation, it’s easy to confuse facts with opinions, feelings with accusations, and requests with demands. How can you express dissatisfaction, explain your own needs, and propose a specific solution while still allowing your conversation partner the opportunity to refuse or suggest an alternative?
Guarantees of the practice of law
Unrestricted access to advocates' accounts poses a risk of client data disclosure — BCU
Information regarding transactions in the bank accounts of an advocate, a law firm, or a bar association from which clients can be identified, as well as the fact and subject matter of a request for legal assistance, the purpose of payments, and the amount of the fee constitutes attorney-client privilege. This rule applies regardless of whether the information also constitutes banking information and is in the possession of a bank.
Guarantees of the practice of law
The contract provides for a video conference, but the court requires in-person appearance: how should an advocate proceed?
Many advocates today work remotely; therefore, their agreements with clients provide for the provision of legal assistance via videoconferencing. However, this form of work does not, in and of itself, create an unconditional obligation for the court to conduct every hearing via videoconference.
Guarantees of the practice of law
Independent oversight is necessary before using CISA materials against an advocate – Lidiya Izovitova
Before the prosecution uses information obtained during covert investigative actions and related to an advocate’s activities, independent procedural oversight must be conducted. It is necessary to determine whether such information is covered by attorney-client privilege and whether it may be disclosed.
Legislation
Handing over a bank card should not automatically constitute a crime – UNBA
Criminal liability for transferring a bank card or access to an account should arise only if it is proven that the person knew the card or account would be used as a means to commit an intentional crime. The mere fact that a payment instrument was transferred or that an account was used by a third party is not sufficient.
Publications
Vasyl Kolishnyi, «Law and Business» Supporting mental health should become part of the professional culture of the Bar, - H. Udovenko
Volodymyr Matsko Extradition during wartime: when the risks outweigh the request
Volodymyr Matsko Extradition as a systemic form of rights violations
Victoria Yakusha, Law and Business The anti-corruption vertical cannot «take care» of the Bar as an institution, - acting head of the HQDCB
Censor.net Protecting advocates – protecting justice: addressing concerns about the new law
Ihor Kolesnykov A BRIEF SUMMARY REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDER ON EXTENDED CONFISCATION IN LATVIA REGARDING FINANCIAL ASSETS OF…
Valentyn Gvozdiy WORKING IN A WAR ZONE
Lydia Izovitova Formula of perfection
