Access to information and attorney-client privilege: three-part test explained by the Ombudsman

Advocacy
15:17 Thu 15.08.24 76 Reviews
Print

According to the law, everyone has the right to access public information. At the same time, access to confidential, secret and proprietary information may be restricted under a set of certain conditions (there are only three).

On August 14, representatives of the Office of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights conducted a training for the Secretariat of the Ukrainian National Bar Association and the Bar Qualification and Disciplinary Commissions on the topic «Application of the three-part test in the activities of bar self-government bodies in access to public information».

Valentyn Gvozdiy, Vice President of the UNBA, BCU emphasized the importance of observing the guarantees of the right to access public information and drew special attention to the specifics related to the practice of law. «When we talk about access to information and what kind of information should be provided or disclosed, it is important to take into account the so-called three-part test, - he said. - We remember that we often have information that contains attorney-client privilege. Such data may be concealed when documents are made public in order to avoid the possibility of disclosing their essence».

According to Art. 22 of the Law «On the Bar and Practice of Law», the attorney-client privilege is any information that has become known to the advocate, assistant advocate, trainee advocate, person who is in an employment relationship with the advocate, about the client, as well as the issues on which the client (person who was denied the conclusion of a legal aid agreement) applied to the advocate, law office, law firm or law office, (a person who was denied the conclusion of the agreement for provision of legal aid) applied to the advocate, law firm or law office, the content of the advocate's advice, consultations, explanations, documents drawn up by him or her, information stored on electronic media, and other documents and information received by the advocate in the course of his or her practice of law. Persons guilty of unauthorized access to or disclosure of the attorney-client privilege shall be liable under the law.

The speaker of the training, Oleksandr Yurchenko, an employee of the Department for Monitoring the Observance of Information Rights of the Secretariat of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights, reminded that Article 6 of the Law «On Access to Public Information» defines three types of information that can be classified as restricted information: confidential, secret and proprietary information.

According to him, secret information refers not only to state secrets. There is a fairly wide list (about thirty types) of other secrets related, in particular, to the exercise of professional activities by persons. This also includes the attorney-client privilege.

The Law «On the Bar and Practice of Law» defines attorney-client privilege, but does not regulate the issue of access to public information and the procedure for its restriction. Therefore, according to O. Yurchenko, when requesting information that may constitute attorney-client privilege, a three-part test should be applied.

Its content is enshrined in part 2 of Article 6 of the Law «On Access to Public Information». Restriction of access to information is carried out in accordance with the law, subject to the following requirements:

1) exclusively in the interests of national security, territorial integrity or public order in order to prevent riots or criminal offenses, to protect public health, to protect the reputation or rights of others, to prevent the disclosure of information received in confidence, or to maintain the authority and impartiality of justice;

2) disclosure of information may cause significant damage to these interests;

3) the harm from disclosure of such information outweighs the public interest in obtaining it.

The representative of the Ombudsman's Office also pointed out that the content of the attorney-client privilege implies that it includes information or documents received from third parties and containing information about them. And such information may be disseminated subject to the requirements of the legislation on personal data protection.

«We are not talking about secret information here, but rather confidential information, personal data. If we open the Law on Personal Data Protection, in particular Article 16, it states that the procedure for third parties to access personal data held by a public information manager is determined by the Law on Access to Public Information. In other words, from the Law «On the Bar and Practice of Law» we have a reference to the Law «On Personal Data Protection», and from there, in turn, there is a reference to the Law «On Access to Public Information». That is, if personal data of third parties are requested that you have in your possession and can be attributed to the attorney-client privilege, then the restriction will be based on a three-part test, through the «mediation» of the Law on Personal Data Protection», - said O. Yurchenko.

He advises to check the practical aspects of the three-part test with the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Administrative Court No. 10 dated September 29, 2016 «On the practice of application of legislation on access to public information by administrative courts».

Popular news

Advocacy

The UNBA is studying additional opportunities to support advocates

The full-scale invasion has seriously affected the mental health of all Ukrainians. There are certain vulnerable groups that have been most affected by the war in their personal and professional lives, including lawyers.

17:57 Tue 10.09.24 100

Advocacy

Everyone deserves protection, the Bar fulfills this requirement of the Constitution

The formation of the opinion in society that lawyers somehow choose their clients incorrectly because some people are not worthy of defense is a very dangerous phenomenon for the state. In the future, our enemies can use it against Ukraine.

13:44 Tue 27.08.24 171

Advocacy

The peculiarities of publishing decisions of the QDCB were explained by the BCU

According to the Law on Access to Public Information, managers of such information are obliged to publish the acts they adopt. At the same time, the decisions made by the qualification and disciplinary commissions of the bar contain both attorney-client privilege and personal data.

16:31 Tue 20.08.24 123

Advocacy

Public perception of the role of lawyers is a global problem, - V. Gvozdiy

«Statements and actions that undermine confidence in the independence of the legal profession and potentially threaten the safety of lawyers ultimately undermine confidence in the entire justice system and the rule of law. No lawyer should be attacked for doing their job».

16:27 Mon 19.08.24 126

Advocacy

UNBA comments on lawyers' «interference» in mobilization processes

Recently, after another scandal, the Volyn Regional Territorial Center for Recruitment and Social Support stated that lawyers should not interfere with the processes of mobilization and military medical examination. The statement has already been commented on by the National Bar Association of Ukraine.

17:37 Fri 16.08.24 153

Advocacy

HCJ engages Valentyn Gvozdiy to develop measures to ensure judicial independence

Valentyn Gvozdiy, Vice President of the Ukrainian National Bar Association and the Bar Council of Ukraine, was appointed to the working group on the development and implementation of measures to ensure the independence of judges and the authority of justice.

13:21 Wed 07.08.24 368

Advocacy

Use of legal remedies is not pressure – BCU

Lidiya Izovitova, the President of the UNBA, BCU appealed to the Prosecutor General's Office and the Council of Prosecutors of Ukraine regarding the inadmissibility of pressure on lawyers who use legal means of defense in the framework of providing legal aid.

14:17 Thu 01.08.24 177

Advocacy

The Council of Europe supports the development of UNBA

The Council of Europe Office in Ukraine will provide all possible support for the development of the Ukrainian National Bar Association and its initiatives for the benefit of Ukrainian society.

12:47 Wed 17.07.24 271

Надішліть файл із текстом публікації у форматі *.doc, фотографію за тематикою у розмірі 640х400 та Ваше фото.

Оберіть файл